Part I. After Dorylaeum
“After a battle, every man counts his losses differently. A prince counts banners, a commander counts soldiers, and a physician counts the wounded. An ordinary soldier counts the familiar faces he will never see again beside the evening fire.”
From the writings of Ansel de Nantes.

another parts
The morning after Dorylaeum began without trumpets. No one sounded the call to rise, shouted orders, or went from tent to tent rousing squires who had overslept. Men woke of their own accord—to the groans of the wounded, the heavy smell of blood and smoke, or simply because sleeping among the dead had proved impossible. Little remained of the night’s coolness. The sun was already rising above the hills, illuminating a valley that only the day before had seemed a fine place to make camp. Now it was littered with broken spears, shattered shields, overturned wagons, and the bodies of men and horses. Seljuks and Christians were buried separately, but they lay mingled together, and until someone turned a fallen man onto his back, it was often impossible to tell which army he had belonged to.
Clavier was buried with the other Normans on a small rise west of the camp. The ground was hard and parched, and the graves had to be hacked out with pickaxes, so the work continued almost until dawn. His sword, belt, and mail shirt were not buried with him. Good weapons were not put into the earth while men remained alive who could use them. Only the wooden cross he had worn beneath his clothing was removed and placed upon his chest. Geoffroi wrapped our commander in his cloak himself, Drogo helped lower the body into the shallow grave, and I threw the first handful of earth onto the cloth. A priest recited a short prayer, and that was the end of it. Neither Robert nor any of the senior warriors made a speech. After such a battle, there were too many dead for each man to receive words of his own.
I scarcely remember returning to our fire. Only Geoffroi, Drogo, and four other men from Clavier’s ten remained there. One lay in a tent with a wounded thigh, two had disappeared during the pursuit, and the others were dead. Yesterday there had been ten of us, not counting squires and servants. Now a single glance was enough to take the roll. No one spoke of what had happened. Drogo silently cleaned his sword, though not a trace of blood remained on the blade. Geoffroi sat with his elbows on his knees, staring into the fire, while I examined the straps of my shield without noticing that I was checking the same buckle for the third time. We had grown accustomed to Clavier always being somewhere nearby: inspecting the horses, scolding the lazy, deciding who would stand watch and who would fetch water. Now he was gone, and with him had vanished the reassuring certainty that someone had already thought of everything for us.
Around noon, an order passed through the camp from the duke: the surviving senior warriors, members of the conrois, and squires were to assemble at his tent. The messenger found us beside the fire, surveyed the empty places, and added more quietly that the remnants of Clavier’s ten were also summoned. Geoffroi rose first, instinctively straightening his surcoat and checking that his sword still hung at his side. Drogo gave me a brief look, as though he wanted to say something, then thought better of it. The three of us went together. None of us asked why Robert wanted us. The answer was too obvious.
About thirty men were already standing before the duke’s tent. Some were wounded and leaned upon their spears; others had come without helmets or shields, wearing torn surcoats and mail blackened with blood. I recognized several sergeants from neighbouring conrois, a young Breton whom Clavier had forced back into line during the first attack, and two Flemings who had fought beside us on the right flank. Almost all had come alone. Behind them stood none of the men they had commanded only yesterday.
Robert did not keep us waiting. He emerged from his tent wearing the same mail in which he had fought the previous day. A deep scratch marked his face, and his left forearm was bandaged, but the duke stood straight and spoke calmly. Beside him were a scribe carrying several wax tablets and an elderly standard-bearer who read out the names of fallen commanders. There was no map and no council of princes. Robert was occupied not with planning the campaign, but with something without which the campaign could not continue at all: rebuilding his own army.
“Guillaume de Mortain’s ten,” the standard-bearer announced.
No one answered.
Robert surveyed the men.
“Who’s the senior survivor?”
A stocky sergeant with a bandaged head stepped out of the second row.
“I am, my lord. Renaud of Bayeux.”
“How many men?”
“Five of my own. Another three joined us during the battle.”
“Then they’re yours as well. You’ll receive reinforcements from Étienne’s men. From this day forward, you’re a commander of ten.”
Renaud dropped to one knee, but Robert immediately ordered him to rise. He expected no thanks, and there was nothing here to congratulate anyone upon. The appointment meant only that the former commander was dead and someone else must now answer for his men. Next came the remnants of Étienne’s conroi, then the men of Guillaume the Red, followed by the Bretons who had lost two senior warriors at once. Each time, almost the same thing happened: name the dead man, establish how many remained, choose the man whom the others had already followed in battle, order him to take charge of new soldiers, and send him to the scribe. The army, shattered into dozens of fragments the previous day, was slowly being put back together.
At last the standard-bearer called:
“Clavier Viel’s men.”
We stepped forward. For an instant, I thought Robert might look past us and ask where our commander was, but the duke had witnessed his death and knew the answer perfectly well. His gaze rested upon each of us before turning to Geoffroi.
“Yesterday, after Clavier was wounded, you held the left end of the line?”
“Yes, my lord.”
“Did the men obey you?”
Geoffroi hesitated.
“Those who could hear me.”
“Those are the only ones you’ll ever have.”
Robert spoke without mockery. He signalled to the scribe and continued.
“From this day forward, you’re a commander of ten. You’ll receive four survivors from Guillaume’s conroi and the men left without a commander beneath the Flemish banner. Find out which of them can still hold a spear, which are fit to serve as archers, and which need feeding and a physician before anything else.”
Geoffroi knelt.
“I serve you, my lord.”
“Serve them.” Robert nodded toward the waiting soldiers. “You’ll be of use to me only so long as you’re of use to your men.”
Geoffroi rose and stepped back. There was neither joy nor pride upon his face. Only a few days earlier, he would surely have found a joke even for an occasion like this. Now he merely pressed his lips together and gave Drogo a brief nod as his friend took his place before the duke.
“You gathered the men beside the baggage train when the cavalry broke through to the tents?” Robert asked.
“I did, my lord.”
“Why didn’t you join Geoffroi?”
“Someone had to protect the horses and the wounded.”
Robert smiled almost imperceptibly.
“So you’ve learned to think before you strike. Clavier would have been surprised.”
For the first time that morning, Drogo raised his eyes.
“I think he’d have called it an accident.”
“Perhaps. But even an accident can be put to good use. From this day forward, you’re a commander of ten. You’ll receive the remnants of two shattered detachments and several new men from the baggage train. Until they learn to stand together, keep them close to my banner.”
“Yes, my lord.”
“And one more thing, Drogo. Clavier could afford to shout at you because he’d known every one of you since your first day of service. You’re getting men, half of whom don’t even understand your dialect. Before demanding their loyalty, make certain they understand your orders.”
Drogo nodded and stepped back.
Now I stood alone before Robert.
I did not know what to expect. Part of me was convinced the duke would appoint me a commander of ten as well. After Nicaea and Dorylaeum, I no longer considered myself an inexperienced boy. In the last battle, I had held the line beside Clavier and helped drive fleeing men back into formation. Yet another part of me understood how foolish that hope was. I had only just turned seventeen, and until yesterday I had always acted under someone else’s command.
“Ansel de Nantes,” Robert said.
“Here, my lord.”
“You were expecting a ten of your own?”
I felt the blood rise to my face, but I did not lie.
“I had thought about it.”
“Good. That means you have ambition. The trouble is that you still confuse experience in battle with the ability to command men.”
I lowered my eyes.
“Yes, my lord.”
“Look at me.”
I obeyed. Robert spoke without anger and made no attempt to humiliate me. He explained his decision much as Clavier had once explained why a boy would do better to take up an axe before a sword.
“You’ve learned well, and you know how to listen. Yesterday, that kept you alive. But a commander must answer for more than his own shield. He must notice that one man’s girth has broken, another hasn’t eaten for two days, a third is frightened, and a fourth is about to do something foolish to prove his courage. Clavier could see all those things at once. You cannot. Not yet.”
The words were fair, and for that very reason they stung more deeply than any reproach.
“What are your orders?”
“You’ll remain with Drogo. Help him assemble his new ten and take the position of senior squire. He knows you, you know him, and his new men will soon need both of you.”
Robert was about to summon the next man when he stopped and turned toward the entrance to his tent.
“Come here.”
A tall man emerged from the shadows, wearing a long mail shirt beneath a dark Roman cloak. A heavy axe hung across his back, though it was not the broad two-handed weapon I had first seen carried by the Varangians at the palace. This was a shorter weapon, better suited to the march. His fair hair had been cut to shoulder length, and his beard was neatly trimmed in the Greek fashion. I recognized him immediately, although since Constantinople I had seen him only a few times in the company of imperial messengers.
Shortbeard looked at me and smiled faintly.
“Monk.”
“Varangian,” I answered before I could stop myself.
Drogo raised an inquisitive eyebrow, but Robert gave him no chance to speak.
“This is Hakon Thorsteinsson. He serves in the basileus’s guard and accompanied the Roman commanders as far as Nicaea. Now, by agreement with the emperor, he’ll be attached to my conroi. He speaks Greek, Armenian, and the language of the Turks. He knows the roads and was fighting in these lands when half of you were still learning to hold wooden swords.”
Hakon listened calmly to the introduction, showing neither pride nor displeasure. Robert turned to Drogo.
“He’ll accompany your ten.”
“Under my command?” Drogo asked cautiously.
“Alongside you, not beneath you. In formation, you command. On the road, in dealings with the locals, and whenever you encounter Romans, you’ll hear what he has to say before making a decision. You may argue as much as you like, but only after the men have been fed, the sentries posted, and the horses watered.”
Drogo studied Hakon.
“Does he at least know how to fight alongside Normans?”
“I know how to fight beside men who leave me enough room to swing my axe,” the Varangian replied without the slightest change of expression.
Several men nearby laughed quietly. Even Robert allowed himself a brief smile.
“Then you’ll manage. Ansel, you’ll remain between them. Drogo will teach you to take responsibility for men. Hakon will teach you to understand the land those men are marching through. A sword alone is not enough in the East.”
At the time, I did not yet realize how important that order would prove. It seemed to me that the duke was merely putting survivors together in whatever way might fill the gaps left by yesterday’s slaughter. Only many years later did I understand that on that very morning, a man had come into my life who would teach me everything Clavier had neither the time nor the means to teach.
The appointments continued almost until noon. One after another, the surviving sergeants, squires, and men of the conrois passed before Robert. Some received commands of ten, others were assigned to new commanders, and still others were sent to the baggage train or to care for the wounded. The duke did not raise his voice once, but by the end of the assembly, his army had regained at least the semblance of order. The new groups scarcely knew one another. The men spoke different dialects and served different lords, but each now knew which banner to gather around and whose orders to obey.
When the last few men remained, Robert wearily rubbed a hand across his face and looked at the scribe.
“How many more?”
“Three groups, my lord.”
The duke nodded toward the waiting men.
“Call the next men from my conroi.”
We moved away from the tent, making room for the others. For me, an entire life had just ended. Clavier’s ten no longer existed. Geoffroi and Drogo had become commanders, I had been given duties for which I was not yet ready, and beside us walked a silent Varangian whom almost no one but me knew. Yet the camp was already returning to its business. Blacksmiths repaired weapons, grooms gathered the surviving horses, and the new commanders counted their new men. War did not permit anyone to mourn the old order for long. It simply took that order away and demanded that another be built at once.
Part II. The First Departure
“We left Europe as one army, but those of us who reached Jerusalem were no longer the same men, nor did we march beneath the same banners. Baldwin was the first to turn aside from the common road. Many called him ambitious at the time. Later, those same men understood that it is usually the ambitious who found states.”
From the writings of Ansel de Nantes.

We left the valley of Dorylaeum two days after the battle. We could not remain any longer. The dead had been buried, the gravely wounded distributed among the wagons, the surviving horses counted, and the new groups of ten had at least learned to gather around their banners. Robert considered that sufficient. His army was not what it had been and never could be again, but it had regained the ability to move.
Within the first hour of marching, we discovered just how thoroughly the battle had mixed the men together. Drogo now commanded two Normans, three Flemings, a Breton, a young squire from Anjou, and an elderly sergeant from Lorraine who understood our orders only when they were accompanied by gestures. Then there were Hakon and me. The Varangian was not formally subordinate to Drogo, yet he took his place beside him so naturally that he might always have belonged to our little company.
Drogo regarded his new position with poorly concealed irritation. Before, he had been responsible for his own weapons, his horse, and his place in the line. Now he had to make certain that a Fleming did not fall behind because of a broken girth, that the Angevin did not drink all his water before noon, and that the Lorrainer understood whose turn it was to stand the night watch. On the very first evening, two of his new men nearly came to blows over a place beside the fire. Drogo separated them, confiscated both their suppers, and assigned them together to the second watch. Afterward, he sat staring into the flames with the expression of a man who had suddenly understood why Clavier had so often looked exhausted before a battle had even begun.
“If one of them murders the other tomorrow,” he muttered, “I’ll abandon the ten and enter a monastery.”
“They won’t take you,” Geoffroi replied. He had stopped beside our fire while making the rounds of his own men. “You know too much about women.”
“Then I’ll remain a commander. It’s less humiliating.”
Geoffroi laughed, though not for long. He too was constantly looking back at his men now, inspecting weapons and counting sentries. His appointment seemed to have aged him overnight. He still found time for jokes, but now he joked not because he was amused himself, but because he could see how tense everyone else was. Sometimes, when giving an order, Geoffroi unconsciously lowered his voice and spoke in Clavier’s short, clipped phrases. The first few times, hearing it caused me something close to physical pain. Then I grew accustomed to it. Good teachers seldom leave behind books or monuments. More often, they live on in the habits, gestures, and words of others.
Hakon kept somewhat apart. He helped post the sentries, spoke several times with Armenian guides, and rode ahead with the scouts every morning, but said almost nothing about himself. At first, Drogo tried to establish just how useful the Varangian really was by asking deliberately simple questions about water, roads, and nearby settlements. Hakon answered calmly and proved right every time. When he warned that a well marked on an old Roman map had dried up, we found nothing but a pit filled with stones. When he advised us to avoid a village, we discovered a few hours later that its inhabitants had fled after poisoning the water source. By the end of the third day, Drogo had stopped questioning every word he said, though he was not yet prepared to admit it aloud.
To me, the Varangian seemed a man I had met before but did not know at all. We had exchanged a few words at the palace, and he had appeared several times among the Byzantine messengers outside Nicaea, but there was an immense gulf between a brief conversation about a beard and serving together. I knew his name, his nickname, and that he served the emperor. Everything else I had to discover for myself.
He spoke Frankish slowly, choosing his words with care, but sometimes used expressions even Drogo had never heard. When praying, he crossed himself in the Greek fashion, while his curses were uttered in a language that resembled the old speech of Norman warriors. At supper, he ate almost anything that found its way into the pot, but refused wine that was too sweet, calling it syrup for children. Strangest of all, he never seemed like an outsider, although he belonged completely to none of the peoples among us.
Our first proper conversation took place a week after Dorylaeum. The column had halted beside a small river where the water had not yet been churned into mud by the hooves of thousands of horses. Drogo had gone to deal with men who had occupied our stretch of the bank, Geoffroi had ridden farther along with his own ten, and I remained behind to fill the waterskins.
Hakon sat on a flat stone with his mail coif removed, scraping dried clay from his boot with a short knife. His beard really was unusually neat for a Varangian, particularly compared with the long moustaches and tangled hair of some of the northerners we had encountered in Constantinople.
“Are you going to stare at my beard forever, or will you eventually ask?” he said without looking up.
I felt embarrassed.
“I already asked.”
“At the palace. We were interrupted.”
“Why did you start trimming it like a Greek?”
Hakon ran a hand across his chin.
“Because a long beard catches in the rings of a mail coif, soaks up sweat, and collects half your supper. In this one matter, at least, the Romans have proved more sensible than the northerners.”
“And your comrades decided you’d turned your back on your ancestors?”
“Some men believe courage lives in their hair. I’ve spent years trying to find it there, without success.”
I laughed. Hakon looked at me and smiled too. For the first time, he seemed not like a silent imperial warrior, but an ordinary man capable of enjoying someone else’s embarrassment.
“Robert said you know these lands,” I continued. “Have you been here before?”
“Several times. With Roman armies, with embassies, and once with a merchant caravan.”
“A Varangian guarding merchants?”
“A Varangian guarding imperial silver that the merchants were supposed to deliver to Constantinople. Does that sound more respectable?”
“A little.”
He put away his knife and nodded toward the waterskin lying beside me.
“Fill it all the way, monk. The next water is a long way off.”
I lowered the waterskin into the river. For a while, we sat in silence, listening to the sounds of the camp and the shouts of the grooms. Before long, some news began passing along the column. First it reached the neighbouring fire, then someone repeated it to the Flemings, and within minutes men all along the riverbank were talking about Baldwin of Boulogne. They claimed that he intended to leave the main army and turn east, toward the lands of the Armenians.
“Is it true?” I asked.
Hakon did not seem surprised.
“Probably.”
“Is he abandoning the crusade?”
“And where do you think the crusade leads?”
“To Jerusalem.”
“For you. Baldwin’s road may lead somewhere else.”
I did not like the answer.
“We all took the cross for the Holy Sepulchre.”
“Men seldom travel so far for only one reason.”
“So he’s looking for land?”
Hakon shrugged.
“He’s a younger brother. There would be little for him at home. Here, he has warriors, a name, and cities in need of a protector. In the East, that can sometimes be enough to make a man a ruler.”
I pulled the full waterskin from the river and tied its neck.
“Can a man really abandon the common army to gain a lordship of his own?”
“He can. The only question is whether it will harm the army or help it.”
“There’ll be fewer men.”
“But there may be friendly territory east of your road. Land that can send grain, horses, and soldiers. Sometimes a thousand men who leave today are more useful than ten thousand who will demand bread tomorrow.”
I remembered Clavier’s words about armies marching on water, oats, and bread. Hakon reasoned differently, but he was speaking of the same thing: war depended on more than the number of swords.
“Do you approve of Baldwin’s decision?”
“I understand it. That’s not the same thing.”
“And what would the emperor say?”
Hakon considered the question, then picked up a small stone and tossed it into the water.
“The basileus would prefer every city in Asia Minor to return to the Empire, and every western prince to go home once victory was won.”
“That won’t happen.”
“Which is precisely why I’m here.”
I looked at him more closely.
“To watch us?”
“Among other things.”
He answered so calmly that I did not immediately grasp what he had said.
“And you admit it openly?”
“You asked.”
“What if I tell Robert?”
“He already knows. A sensible prince always understands why a foreigner has been placed in his company.”
I had expected excuses, but Hakon offered none. He served the emperor and saw nothing shameful in it. Yet Robert had entrusted him to our ten as though certain the Varangian would do us no harm.
“Then why do you help us?”
“Because for now, our aims are the same. You want to cross lands held by the Turks. The emperor wants the Turks to lose those lands. I don’t have to love Normans to show them a safe road.”
“You don’t like us?”
Hakon glanced at my sword.
“My father fought against the Normans.”
“In England?”
He nodded.
“After your conquest, he left his home and came to Constantinople. I grew up among men who considered Duke William a usurper and the Normans a band of robbers.”
I felt an unpleasant chill despite the heat of the day. My father had served William the Conqueror and died while suppressing a Saxon rebellion. Perhaps he had fought men just like Hakon’s father.
“My father was one of William’s bodyguards.”
“I know.”
“Robert told you?”
“No. You carry Hugues de Nantes’s sword. The older Varangians remember the names of some of the Conqueror’s men.”
I did not know what to say. Not long ago, such a truth might have made us enemies. Now we sat beside the same river in a land equally foreign to us both.
“Then you ought to hate me.”
“For what? You hadn’t even been born. Nor did I choose the banner beneath which my father fought.”
Hakon rose from the stone and pulled on his mail coif.
“Remember this, monk: if a man inherits every war his ancestors fought, he’ll have no time left to live his own life.”
Those were the first words of Hakon’s that I remembered forever. Clavier had usually given me ready answers—simple, reliable, and immediately useful. Hakon spoke differently. His words left me with more questions than before.
The next day, the rumour was confirmed. Baldwin of Boulogne was leaving the main army and heading east with several hundred knights and foot soldiers. It was said that Armenian rulers had called upon him for help, that cities were opening their gates to him, and that wealthy Edessa was ready to welcome a western prince. Most ordinary soldiers knew no more about those lands than I did. To us, there were only Jerusalem, Antioch, and the endless road between them. Baldwin, however, could already see a place on the map for a state of his own.
We watched his departure from a small hill. His column was modest compared with the main army, but it moved swiftly and in good order. A banner bearing a cross flew above the horsemen, there were scarcely any wagons, and Armenian guides rode at the front. Some crusaders shouted curses after them, accusing Baldwin of betraying his vow. Others watched with envy. In the East, land and power had suddenly ceased to seem like privileges of birth beyond a man’s reach. They could be won, provided one arrived at the right city with enough armed men.
Drogo stood beside me, squinting into the sun.
“Some go off in search of kingdoms, while we keep marching toward a tomb.”
“The Holy Sepulchre,” Geoffroi corrected him.
“Calling it holy doesn’t make it any less a tomb.”
Geoffroi grinned.
“Thinking about death again?”
“Someone has to, while the rest of you dream of becoming counts.”
Hakon, standing a little apart, watched Baldwin depart without condemnation.
“In a few years,” he said, “men will argue over whether this departure was treachery or wisdom.”
“And what do you think?” Drogo asked.
“I think the victor will call it wisdom. Had he lost, they’d have called him a traitor.”
Drogo grunted.
“At last, you’ve said something I understand.”
Baldwin’s column gradually disappeared among the hills. We did not yet know that his journey would lead to the creation of the first crusader state—the County of Edessa. To us, it was merely the departure of one prince and several hundred soldiers who might be sorely missed in the next battle. Only later did I understand that on that day, the crusade first ceased to be a single march toward a single holy place. Other roads were beginning to branch away from the common path—toward lands, titles, alliances, and future principalities.
That evening, Robert ordered us to prepare to resume the march. Ahead lay the mountain passes, Cilicia, and the road to one of the greatest cities of the East. The new groups of ten were still learning to act together, Drogo was growing accustomed to command, Geoffroi increasingly spoke in the voice of our dead mentor, and Hakon Shortbeard took his place beside our fire for the first time not as the emperor’s man, but as a companion on the road.
Friendship was still a long way off.
Yet it was then that the first barrier between us disappeared—the one that the swords of our fathers had drawn so many years before.
Part III. Beneath the Walls of Antioch
“Nicaea taught us that cities could be taken through patience. Antioch showed us that patience, too, could run out—along with bread, wine, and blood.”
From the writings of Ansel de Nantes.
We reached Antioch in the last days of October. During the long months of our journey, I had seen the walls of Constantinople and Nicaea, yet even they had not prepared me for my first sight of the ancient Syrian capital. The city lay in the broad valley of the Orontes, pressed against the slopes of Mount Silpius. Its fortifications did not merely surround houses and markets. They climbed rocky spurs, clung to the summits, and rose so high that the mountains themselves seemed to have been turned into a fortress. Above the city stood a citadel carved into the rock and protected by steep slopes, while below stretched an endless chain of towers, gates, and walls, in places concealed by gardens, streams, and marshy lowlands.
Drogo stared at the fortifications for a long time, shielding his eyes from the sun.
“How many towers are there?”
Hakon, riding beside him, shrugged.
“Enough.”
“That’s not a number.”
“And counting them would be pointless. Even if you knew the exact number, there wouldn’t be any fewer.”
Geoffroi grinned, though his expression soon grew serious. Since Dorylaeum, he no longer looked at a fortress through the eyes of a young man in a conroi, wondering where he might distinguish himself. He looked at it as a commander who would have to lead his men beneath its arrows.
Before us stood a city that the entire crusader army was too small to encircle completely. Antioch’s walls extended for many thousands of paces, and certain stretches were defended not only by stone but by the terrain itself. To the south, the Orontes approached the fortifications. Near the Dog Gate and the Garden Gate, streams converged to form marshy ground. In the east, the walls climbed toward the citadel and the Iron Gate, while the western roads connected the city with Harim and the sea coast. Even our enormous army could do little more than occupy positions near the main exits, leaving wide gaps between the camps.
The princes divided the approaches to the city among themselves. Bohemond of Taranto and his men took positions near St Paul’s Gate, with Tancred, Robert of Flanders, and our duke’s Normans encamped nearby. Raymond of Toulouse and Bishop Adhemar established themselves closer to the Dog Gate, while Godfrey of Bouillon occupied the southern road leading toward the Orontes and the Garden Gate. The remaining detachments filled the spaces between them as best they could.
From a distance, it resembled a tight ring of siege camps. But one needed only to climb a hill to see the truth: the ring was broken in many places, and the garrison could still make sorties, receive news, and probably move small parties through the more distant gates.
“We haven’t surrounded the city,” I observed as we studied the defences from one of the slopes.
“We have,” Hakon replied. “We simply haven’t sealed it off.”
“Isn’t that the same thing?”
“To a man standing outside, almost. To a man inside, there’s an enormous difference.”
At first, the siege seemed astonishingly easy. The land around Antioch was fertile. Fruit still hung in the orchards, grain and wine could be found in the surrounding villages, and herds that had not been driven away with their owners supplied the camp with meat. After the scorched plains of Asia Minor, the Orontes valley seemed to us a blessed land. Men ate their fill, horses received fodder, and the city’s garrison scarcely troubled our positions.
Already, men in the camps were debating how many weeks it would take to force Antioch to surrender and which prince would have the honour of entering its gates first. Some insisted that after their defeats at Nicaea and Dorylaeum, the Turks had lost their resolve and would not dare resist for long.
Hakon listened to such talk without enthusiasm.
“The garrison is studying you,” he said one day as we returned from a patrol along the road to St Paul’s Gate. “While you have food and your men are content, Yaghi-Siyan loses nothing. Winter hasn’t begun, reinforcements haven’t arrived, and you’re showing him where you post your sentries, how you change the watches, and which roads your supplies travel along.”
Drogo looked toward the silent walls.
“So the sorties will begin soon?”
“When they know where it will hurt you most.”
Shortbeard proved right.
The first serious attacks came along the road to the Iron Bridge, which passed not far from St Paul’s Gate. Beyond the bridge lay Harim, a fortified settlement from which small Muslim detachments could harass our positions, attack supply convoys, and disappear before the heavy cavalry had time to form up. Several times they attacked men sent out to gather fodder and timber, and soon they were appearing almost daily.
Bohemond and Robert of Flanders assembled their troops and attempted to capture Harim, but they could not take the stronghold by a sudden assault. The enemy withdrew behind its walls, waited for the attack to pass, and returned to the road as soon as the crusaders went back to their camps.
Our ten escorted convoys between the camp and the Iron Bridge several times. These journeys soon ceased to seem like ordinary duty. The enemy might appear from behind any hill, from the orchards, or from the thickets beside the road. We marched with shields raised, sent scouts far ahead, and kept the wagons close together so that, in the event of an attack, they could be turned into a makeshift fortification.
Hakon almost always rode at the front, speaking with local Armenians and carefully examining the road, yet even he could not foresee every sortie. Several times, we returned to camp with wounded men and empty carts because the drivers, frightened by arrows, had abandoned their teams and fled.
“We’re the ones besieging them,” Drogo muttered one day, “yet somehow the roads belong to them.”
“Because walls don’t stop a man from walking out through a gate,” Hakon replied. “For that, another man has to be standing in front of it.”
Raymond of Toulouse was faring no better. Near the Dog Gate, marshland lay between the walls and the meeting of two streams. A bridge crossed one of them, allowing the garrison to send out small detachments quickly and attack the siege works. Raymond’s men tried several times to destroy the crossing, but the defenders protected it with arrows from the walls and immediately drove off anyone who approached.
The count then ordered a wooden tower to be built. It was intended to block the bridge, shelter the men, and provide a position from which to attack the gate.
We watched the construction from a neighbouring sector. Under the cover of large shields, carpenters assembled the frame, crossbowmen returned fire from the walls, and labourers hurriedly carried logs and planks forward. The Turkish archers fired without pause. Arrows struck shields, buried themselves in the timber, and found gaps between the shelters. Every new level of the tower cost several lives, but the structure gradually rose above the marshy ground. It seemed that with a little more work, Raymond’s men might truly establish themselves beside the bridge.
The garrison did not allow them to finish.
The gates suddenly opened, and Muslim infantry rushed out before the builders could take cover. The crossbowmen loosed several volleys, but the attackers crossed the bridge, drove back the covering force, and set the tower alight. The dry timber caught fire quickly. Raymond’s men tried to extinguish the flames, dragged away the wounded, and fought at the very foot of the structure, but before long only a blackened frame remained.
Later, the count ordered three mangonels to be erected to batter the walls with stones, but they too achieved little. Their missiles chipped away at the masonry and shattered battlements, yet Antioch was far too vast for a handful of machines to inflict serious damage upon its defences.
The bridge near the Dog Gate was finally rendered unusable by the simplest possible means. Men began piling enormous stones, felled trees, and earth upon it until the crossing became an impassable heap. I watched dozens of labourers spend several days dragging everything they could lift toward the stream, and I could not help remembering Clavier’s words about fortresses rarely being taken by the sword. At Antioch, we were learning again and again that war required not only brave knights, but hundreds of men willing to carry stones for hours beneath enemy fire.
Not everyone, however, was willing to wait.
A few days after our arrival, a grey-haired old man appeared in the camp, calling himself a pilgrim. He wandered from fire to fire, telling anyone who would listen that a vision had revealed to him a place where the walls of Antioch could be taken in a single determined assault. In some versions of the tale, an angel had appeared to him. In others, it was St George. By evening, some men were already swearing that the Lord Himself had promised victory to whoever first climbed the wall.
The story changed with every new teller, but its meaning remained the same: there was no need to prepare siege engines, wait for a general order, or study the fortifications. All that was required was faith.
I saw men laugh at the old pilgrim. But there were far more who wanted to believe him. After months of marching, battles, and hardship, the thought that a mighty fortress might fall through a single act of determination was too tempting to resist.
Several dozen young knights and foot soldiers gathered at night, found a long ladder, and carried it toward the section of wall the pilgrim had indicated. They did not inform the princes or prepare any covering force. Squires followed them, along with a priest carrying a cross and a crowd of curious onlookers convinced they were about to witness a miracle.
The commotion reached our camp after sunset. Geoffroi heard the shouting first and assembled his ten, believing the garrison had made a sortie. We hurried toward the walls and soon saw a solitary ladder leaning against the masonry. Men were already climbing it, pushing one another and struggling to reach the battlements first.
Torches flared along the walls. The defenders began shouting, and then stones came crashing down.
The first blow split the edge of the ladder.
The second knocked several men from it.
The third struck directly into the group gathered at its foot.
Archers fired at almost point-blank range. The men tried to continue climbing, but the ladder shuddered, pulled away from the wall, and toppled backward with everyone still upon it.
The assault was over before we could reach it.
The survivors dragged away the wounded. Some prayed, others cursed the old pilgrim, who was nowhere to be seen. The defenders shouted from the walls and continued shooting at the retreating men until they disappeared behind the shields of the detachments coming to their aid.
Geoffroi placed our men across the road and ordered them to cover the withdrawal. He spoke briefly and confidently, using almost the same words Clavier had once used.
“Shields higher. No running. Pass the wounded to the rear. Hold the line.”
For an instant, it seemed to me that our old commander was beside us again. I even turned my head, expecting to see his battered helmet and angry face. But the man before me was Geoffroi—exhausted, covered in mud, no longer the young member of the conroi who had once laughed about the miller’s daughter on the road to Caen.
The following morning, no one mocked those who had taken part in the night assault. The folly of their plan was obvious, but too many understood why they had attempted it. We had come to the East believing that we were carrying out the will of God, and so every dream, prophecy, or rumour could seem like a sign. Faith helped men endure hunger and fear, but sometimes that same faith sent them against the walls of an entire city with nothing but a single ladder.
The situation began to change only in the middle of November, when a Genoese fleet arrived in the harbour of St Symeon. The ships brought provisions, fresh soldiers, carpenters, builders, tools, and materials that the besieging army desperately needed. For the first time in a long while, fresh flour, salted fish, wine, and iron for repairing weapons appeared in the camp. With the supplies came the hope that Antioch could not merely be surrounded, but truly cut off from the outside world.
To protect the road from Harim, work began on a small fortress on the slopes of Mount Staurin. It was named Malregard—the Evil Watch. The name suited the place. The fortification was intended to overlook the road to the Iron Bridge and prevent Yaghi-Siyan’s detachments from suddenly descending upon our camps. The men worked quickly, using stone, timber, and earth, while the new Genoese craftsmen directed construction more skilfully than many knights could have done.
Around the same time, Bohemond finally succeeded in drawing the garrison of Harim into the open and destroying it, after which attacks from the northwest became less frequent.
But the road to the sea remained dangerous.
To reach the harbour of St Symeon, one had to cross the Orontes by a bridge not far from the city walls. The ground before it lay within range of the towers, and the garrison could launch sudden sorties through the nearest gates. Convoys passed that way only under heavy escort, and even then, not all returned.
For that reason, a new crossing began to be built farther downstream, near Godfrey’s camp. Boats were placed side by side, bound together with ropes, and covered with wooden planking. The resulting bridge looked fragile, but it allowed men to reach the harbour without passing directly beneath the city walls. By Christmas, men, horses, and wagons were already crossing it.
Thus ended the first, still relatively prosperous period of the siege.
There was food in the camps for the time being. Genoese ships maintained our connection with the sea. The first fortifications were rising around the city, and the princes still believed that Antioch would fall before the true winter arrived.
But the walls remained standing.
The garrison was growing accustomed to our movements, the surrounding villages were gradually emptying, and every sack of grain had to be brought from farther away.
We still called ourselves the besiegers and looked upon the city as our prize.
Very soon, we would discover that hunger recognizes no walls—and that it can lay siege to both sides at once.
